• If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Our new Metal Polishes put to the test




    We're starting to get more and more inquiries into the effectiveness of these three new metal polishes - Heavy Cut, Medium Cut and Finishing Metal Polish - so we thought we would put together a little demo panel for you.

    What we started with was a flat panel of bare, high polished aluminum. We then compromised the appearance in two different ways - by acid dipping a section to simulate what happens when a strong acid based wheel cleaner is sprayed onto bare aluminum wheels, and by DA sanding with 1500 grit and then 3000 grit Unigrit Finishing Discs to totally eliminate all gloss from the surface.

    We then tried each of the three metal polishes to get a feel for the cutting or defect removing abilities of each, as well as the quality of finish offered by each. At the end of it all the test panel looks like the image below. The center strip is the "control" section of virgin, high polished aluminum, and it's how the entire panel started out. The upper third was acid dipped, and on the far right side of that strip is the result of polishing with just the Finishing Metal Polish. The bottom section is the 1500/3000 grit sanded area, with the two test spots being Heavy Cut Metal Polish on the left, and Medium Cut Metal Polish in the center of the section.




    In all cases polishing was done by hand with a fresh foam wax applicator and residue wiped with a microfiber towel. No terry cloth applicators, no machine work - just hand application with a typical yellow foam wax applicator pad. Here's a close up of the "control" section, through the center of the panel. The little bit of cloudiness you see along the top edge is from the acid dip migrating under the masking tape. We didn't bother cleaning that up, and if you look in the image above you can see it clearly across the line of demarcation between the "control" strip and the acid bath strip. But this "control" section is a nice, clear, mirror image polished aluminum.


    As the first image shows, the lower strip on the panel was DA sanded with 1500 and 3000 grit media, rendering the reflections non existent. Here's a close up of the lower right hand corner after sanding.


    In the center of the sanded strip is this, a close up of the area hand polished with just the Medium Cut Polish. While far from perfect, it is a dramatic improvement. Still, this tells us that if you do have to sand your polished aluminum piece then Medium Cut Polish is probably not the best choice to remove the sanding marks by hand. Similarly, if your metal surface is extremely oxidized, again, Medium Cut may not be sufficient to clean everything up.


    This is a close up of the far left side of the sanded strip, this time done only with Heavy Cut Polish, but still by hand. This shows a huge improvement in clarity and gloss, and a follow up with the Finishing Polish should bring back the full gloss and lustre of this polished aluminum. Why do we suggest going straight from this Heavy Cut result to the Finishing Polish rather than doing an intermediate step with the Medium Cut Polish? See the following images for the answer.


    Here's a close up of the acid stained upper strip of the test panel. While the reflections are still sharp, the finish is very cloudy and flat. Again, if you mistakenly spray a strong acid based chrome wheel cleaner onto your high polished aluminum wheels, this is the sort of problem you can expect to deal with. Granted, the staining may not be this uniform, but the overall severity will be quite similar.


    Finally, this is a close up of the upper right corner of the test panel, showing the results of hand polishing the acid stained area with just Finishing Polish and a yellow foam applicator pad. With very little effort we're right back to the sharp reflections and high level of clarity shown in the "control" section. One step, by hand.


    When you compare the above acid stained image to the Heavy Cut Polish test area on the sanded panel, and then look at what Finishing Polish could do to a very similar level of degradation, we're confident that in that in the case of the sanded section a simple two step of Heavy Cut and Finishing Polish would be a fantastic two step process to restore this panel.

    So, what about the effectiveness of the Medium Cut Polish? Is this demo a fail for that product. No, not at all. In this demo we're only light damage and very extreme damage. There are plenty of situations that would fall in between these two extremes, and that's where the Medium Cut Polish would come into play. Would you need to follow Medium Cut with Finishing? Well, as so often happens, the real answer is "it depends". How did the surface respond to the polishing? What are your goals?

    These metal polishes are safe on all bare metal surfaces, but we do not recommend the Heavy Cut Polish for use on chrome due to the aggressive nature of the abrasives. And in many cases you may not even need an aggressive applicator, such as terry cloth or even microfiber, either of which might even mar a very delicate, extremely highly polished surface.

    But whether you're dealing with heavy oxidation, deeper scratches that might require light sanding to remove, light chemical staining, or just a slightly weathered finish, we've got a metal polish to bring back the luster, clarity and gloss you used to have.
    Michael Stoops
    Senior Global Product & Training Specialist | Meguiar's Inc.

    Remember, this hobby is supposed to be your therapy, not the reason you need therapy.

  • #2
    Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

    Thats a huge improvement, How much is this metal polish?????

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

      Here's the full run down on the new metal polishes:

      Originally posted by Michael Stoops View Post



      Heavy Cut Metal Polish

      Product Attributes:
      • For use on neglected wheels
      • Works on all unfinished metals
      • Works to diminish oxidation and pitting on all uncoated metals
      • Heavy abrasives - Our most aggressive cutting action to remove deep scratches
      • Can be used by hand or with the DynaCone
      • Use Finish Cut (see below) for more brilliant shine


      Size:
      4.2 oz.
      Part Number: G15105
      MSRP: $6.99


      ________________________________

      Medium Cut Metal Polish

      Product Attributes:
      • For use with wheels that need to be polished
      • Works on all unfinished metals
      • Works to diminish oxidation and pitting on all uncoated metals
      • Mild abrasives - Abrasives in formula provide strong enough cutting action to remove scratches
      • Can be used by hand or with the DynaCone
      • Leaves a bright shine
      • Can be followed with Finish Cut (see below) if desired


      Size:
      4.2 oz.
      Part Number: G15205
      MSRP: $6.99


      ________________________________

      Finishing Metal Polish

      Product Attributes:
      • For use with wheels that are in near new condition
      • Works on all unfinished metals
      • Will remove light oxidation
      • Very light abrasives - A light finishing product to really enhance the end result - a flawless finish
      • Can be used by hand or with the DynaCone
      • Leaves a flawless finish
      • Could use also use this product as a second step to the Medium Cut or Heavy Cut Polish


      Size:
      5 oz.
      Part Number: G15605
      MSRP: $12.99
      Michael Stoops
      Senior Global Product & Training Specialist | Meguiar's Inc.

      Remember, this hobby is supposed to be your therapy, not the reason you need therapy.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

        Thanks for the comprehensive review Michael! I've been very curious about the new line if metal polishes since the recent announcement and your demo has answered my questions. Between the race car I care for, which has a bunch of aluminum and chrome, as well as the various bits on my Camino that I'm trying to keep OEM-looking, metal polishes have always had a place on my shelves.


        I've been using one of the medium grades of Nuvite for years, usually followed my NXT polysh, but Nuvite is quite pricey and difficult to obtain. Having some aggressive grades of polish available from Meguiar's should fill all my needs.
        Thanks again,
        Bill

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

          Originally posted by Michael Stoops View Post
          Here's the full run down on the new metal polishes:

          Thanks

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

            Very nice. I bought some for the two cars I'm restoring, but what do I protect it with once it is polished?
            Richard's Car Restoration
            How to polish and restore stainless and aluminum trim

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

              Depending on the location, etc, you could wax it, you could use the Brake Dust Barrier, or the Marine Metal Guard.
              2017 Subaru WRX Premium - WR Blue

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

                I used my Heavy-cut this week, and have a mixed review. yes it makes things sparkle, and cuts faster than most bars for the buffing wheel, but not as fast as the black bar. The main advantage is that it does not build up like the waxy stuff in the bars.

                The disadvantage is that the liquid separates from the paste in the tube, so when it comes out the liquid goes its way and the paste often accumulates on to the sides of the threaded opening, so you have to wipe it off and then onto the part. Messy for the gloves if you are wearing safety gloves.

                Also, as the part heats up while polishing, the product begins to run, or has a hard time adhering when applying to a warm part.

                But it does cut through and leave a shine.



                And my aluminum intake manifold

                Richard's Car Restoration
                How to polish and restore stainless and aluminum trim

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Our new Metal Polishes put to the test

                  I will be getting all 3 of these new products!

                  like you BillyJack I love working with NXT all metal polysh, used to polish bare aluminum rims and fuel tanks all the time at a previous job years ago and it's something else to set for hours just on 1 hundred gallon tank to bring to a mirror sshine but fun.

                  Has anyone tried using these products with a Rotory, DA or the DA power system? and if so what is your thoughts? Any review with pics?

                  Thanks michael for doing the review just the thing I've been waiting for!!!
                  ''USE THE LEAST AGGRESSIVE PRODUCT TO GET THE JOB DONE RIGHT''
                  You Don't Know What You Can Do Until You Try '' TECHNIQUE IS EVERYTHING''
                  Test Hoods Are Cheap And Most Of The Time Free

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X
                  gtag('config', 'UA-161993-8');