• If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

    I've wanted to do this for some time and finally got around to it. Unfortunately, my DSLR wasn't charged up and I couldn't find the battery charger for it, so my iPhone 4S camera had to suffice. At some point I'd like to redo this with better photographs, but I think these will suffice.

    I set out to compare these two waxes side by side to see which one gave a better look. I've got an upcoming detail of a black car and wanted to not spend an hour with both of them in my hand deciding which to apply - so I'm testing them out today.

    The test vehicle is a 2007 Chevy Equinox that belongs to my mom. It's a daily driver, but the paint is in pretty good shape. It has some minor swirls, but in this case that was preferable. People around here often say waxes are almost impossible to differentiate between on a well prepped surface. Hopefully, this means you can differentiate between them on a surface that isn't well prepped. By choosing this car vs. one that was immaculate and freshly prepped, I was hoping to get the effect of the wax only, vs. the compound, polish, and wax combo.

    My process for the comparison:

    1) Spray down hood with Last Touch.
    2) Clay, using LT 1:1 as lubricant.
    3) Apply Gold Class & Ultimate Wax by hand, wait 30 minutes, wipe off.
    4) Apply a second coat after about an hour, wait 30 minutes, wipe off.

    Here are the pictures:


    The surface felt pretty smooth to begin with, but the car hadn't been clayed in a few months so I decided to take the few minutes and do it to make the surface as smooth as possible. As you can see the clay picked up a few contaminants left behind after quick-detailing.





    The two waxes on the unwaxed hood. I only waxed the hood, as this made for the most logical test panel. The GCCP went onto the passenger side, the UW went onto the driver side. (Yes I know I need to clip the tags off of my supreme shines!)






    Here are the two waxes during the drying process. The Gold Class on the passenger side is applied a bit heavier, as it doesn't spread out quite as easily as UW and I really wanted to ensure every square milimeter of the hood was covered.



    These two images show the final product, after the second coat of wax has been wiped off. It's tough for me to discern any difference between the two sides as I walk look at them from these angles. However.....take a look at the next picture:




    The left side of the car (Gold Class) is dramatically darker. The right side of the hood (UW) to my eyes looks a little bit crisper, but it's hard to notice anything else besides the darkening effect. This is interesting to me because I've heard UW is supposed to give a darkening effect as well. Ideally I would have done this in thirds, with one of the sections having no wax. For next time, I suppose.

    Final Observations:
    - Gold Class darkens the paint considerably more than Ultimate Wax.
    - Ultimate Wax seems to impart a crisper reflection than Gold Class.
    - Ultimate Wax is considerably easier to apply and remove. I did apply the Gold Class a little bit thick, but even so, anyone has who has used both will agree I suspect.
    - As for which I prefer, I'd probably go with Ultimate Wax as the enhanced reflective clarity gives the impression of a slicker, more mirrored surface.

  • #2
    Cool comparison. Interesting results. I'll still stick with the Ultimate Wax as well.

    By the way, how do you like that Equinox? We've got one as well and I hate the stupid thing death. It's just a cheap car imo. It has become the family grocery getter. Don't get me started on the loud beeping it makes when you open a door and the key is in the ignition or whatever.
    Always searching for the best.... Keep it country!
    ---------
    SkiDoo Snowmobiles!

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

      Thanks for this test. Interesting results. It's often said Ultimate Wax needs a long cure time for a second coat. I wonder what influence a 60 minute cure time has opposed to say 12 hours.

      I agree with your thoughts on the last photograph, but the next to last looks opposite with the driver's side being darker.

      Have you looked it over hours or a day later? Still a visible difference?

      Again, thanks for this demonstration.

      "fishing for swirls in a sea of black"
      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
      David

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

        A few hours later I still think the Gold Class side is slightly darker. It's a very subtle difference. I have an extremely difficult time telling the two sides apart. I've had a few other people look and take a look, and they can't tell a difference. Static pictures are difficult -- they really don't show you how the car looks when you shift your vision and see the light angle change. Both are good waxes. I would give the nod to UW simply because it lasts longer.

        I will put another coat of UW on tomorrow as to give this one time to properly cure and see if I notice any differences. I may experiment with topping the UW with GCCP, as I've heard this is fairly popular.

        As for the Equinox, it is a cheap car. Ours works just fine, but I don't suspect it will last forever. My parents bought it because they wanted a cheap SUV to haul things around in and to get around in the winter months here. We know the dealer here personally and got an absolute steal on it. For that it works acceptably. It does have a pretty nice paint finish on it, for what it's worth.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

          Nice review, both waxes work well as you've shown, really depends on what one is after. GOld class one can say wins in the looks department, or if one is after depth and darkening effect but loses out in durability. Ultimate wax does offer some darkening effect, but not as intensely as gold class but counters with a bit more brightness and crisp reflections and definitely more durability. For me, i prefer the slightly brighter/crisper look of the ultimate wax.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

            It is common knowledge that carnauba wax will always win for looks, however it is not as durable as UW and will not last long. Cool comparison though...
            2010 F150 FX4 and 2001 Ford Escape
            Meguiars All the Way!!!!!!!

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

              The carnauba wins for looks if your'e after the "warm glow," as it's commonly described. If you want the sharper, crisper reflections I'd go with UW. Honestly though, it's extremely hard to tell a difference with either product when you're looking at it in person, so you might as well choose the more durable product.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

                Yup, under normal circumstances the difference in looks is virtually impossible to tell. One has to be at the right angle and light intensity to see the difference in darkness and crispness of reflections. Still, a very good and informative review and comparison

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

                  Interesting!

                  One thing I have noticed using UWLiquid, is when first wiped off there appears to be 'splotchy areas', meaning some are MUCH darker than others. If you just watch them during the actually cure, they will all become the same 'color'. Just an observation.

                  Thank you for doing the side by side...

                  Bill

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

                    Originally posted by BillE View Post
                    Interesting!

                    One thing I have noticed using UWLiquid, is when first wiped off there appears to be 'splotchy areas', meaning some are MUCH darker than others. If you just watch them during the actually cure, they will all become the same 'color'. Just an observation.

                    Thank you for doing the side by side...

                    Bill
                    I had noticed this too. When first applying ULW, I tried to rub these splotches "off" but by the time I was done, the rest had actually darkened. I was sure of this darkening effect the next time I applied ULW when I didn't have the time to try to wipe off the splotches, but the next day, they were gone.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Gold Class Carnauba Plus & Ultimate Paste Wax compared side by side.

                      Interesting test - thanks for taking the time to do this. We think you would find that, had you sectioned the hood into thirds instead of just half, you would have seen some darkening with the UW. Certainly not as much as the GC, but still some. Due to the hydrophobic polymers in UW you should get tighter water beading with that side. There are always going to be trade offs with any wax or sealant, and since we all have our own personal preferences, wants and needs with a wax, we're going to react to them a bit differently. That's a major reason why Meguiar's offers so many different waxes - you're not all looking for exactly the same thing, and you don't all like exactly the same thing.
                      Michael Stoops
                      Senior Global Product & Training Specialist | Meguiar's Inc.

                      Remember, this hobby is supposed to be your therapy, not the reason you need therapy.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      gtag('config', 'UA-161993-8');