• If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

    We were recently blessed with great new 2012 products and I'm sure everyone is excited to try them out. We've recently had a lot of reviews for other products such as the UWWA, Perfect Clarity, and Gold Class QD/QW. I decided to add one review to the pack - behold the Meguiar's Brake Dust Barrier. This product has intrigued me a lot and I'm curious as to whether this product works or not. Here's what the product looks like:



    Product Claims:
    • Makes your wheels easier to clean!
    • Outlasts other wheel protector products
    • Safe for all wheels - even chrome


    Product Description:
    We all love clean wheels, but wouldn't it be nice to have them without the work? Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier uses advanced technology to provide a barrier between dirt and your rims.

    Just spray a light coating to clean, dry wheels. you'll notice dirt & grime do not bond - so it'll take less time & work to clean your wheels. Plus, it lasts for weeks - so no need to re-apply every time you clean your wheels.

    Directions:
    1. Hold can 6 inches away and spray onto wheel until applied areas are lightly coated. Do not over-saturate.
    2. Allow to dry for 3-5 minutes. Avoid wiping the surface while product is drying.

    Tip: If excess product runs onto tire, wipe off immediately. Product can be removed with rubbing alcohol, if needed.

    So onto the process. I started off with clean wheels as shown below:



    I was only going to test this product on the front wheels, where the brake dust accumulation is mostly seen. In order to make sure that the product bonds as perfect as possible, I clayed the wheels first to ensure all bonded contaminants are removed.





    The shot below shows the clay after 1 wheel. It wasn't so bad.



    I think that Last Touch as some polymers or shining agents on it. To make sure that the surface is completely clean, I sprayed IPA to the wheel after claying and then wiped it off afterwards.



    I first worked on the passenger side front wheel. What I did was to tape and cover the right half of the wheel. I used the manufacturer's symbol in the center cap as my point of reference. I applied the brake dust barrier on the left half of the wheel while the right half of the wheel is covered with tape and a newspaper sheet. I did this to ensure that the brake dust barrier wouldn't contaminate the right half of the wheel. Here are some pictures showing the process:

    Only the left half of the wheel exposed:


    Spraying the product on the wheel:


    The instructions said to apply a thin coat to the wheels. I failed to do that because I was trying to ensure I have complete coverage. As a result of doing so, I had some spray running down on some parts of the wheel. Oh well. I hope I didn't compromise the effectiveness of the product.

    On the right half of the passenger side front wheel, I compared the brake dust barrier to my preferred method of wheel protection: Meguiar's Cleaner Wax. I applied cleaner wax on the right half of the wheel and buffed it off as shown below:





    Here is the passenger side front wheel all done:


    I'm going to be checking how this product stacks up against cleaner wax. Will it provide some protection to the wheel? Will it also last longer than the cleaner wax?

    Now let's move on to the driver's side front wheel. I did the same process as the passnger side except that I didn't use anything on the right side. This wheel only has a coat of brake dust barrier on the left side while the right side is completely stripped down. Here are some pictures showing the process:

    Only the left half of the wheel exposed:


    Spraying the product on the wheel:


    Here is the driver side front wheel all done:


    For this side, the plan is to check how effective this product really is. Will it make cleaning wheels a lot easier? Will it really provide a barrier against brake dust?

    I will provide timely updates and show you guys any difference in brake dust accumulation and whether or not it makes it easier to clean. By that I mean by hosing it down with water. Cleaning it with soapy water solution will make the wheels clean regardless if it's maintained properly.

    I might not provide weekly updates because I drive 90-95% freeway and seldom brake. In any case, I will provide updates when I can show some difference.

    Date of application: 2/19/2012
    Mileage: 39,545 miles
    2011 Car Crazy Showcase SEMA Team

  • #2
    Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

    I am looking forward to your findings Marc.

    Hopefully most of the dirt and grime can be removed with just a blast of the pressure washer.
    Nick
    Tucker's Detailing Services
    815-954-0773
    2012 Ford Transit Connect

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

      Interesting test, Marc. Gonna keep an eye on this.
      Learning new things everyday

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

        Subscribed.

        Nice write-up and great test idea, Marc.

        Looking forward to see how the product stands up.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

          This sounds like a Myth Busters clip LOL, Sounds like a good test, TIA for your efforts. I was looking to try the product in March at TNOG.
          BMW ZSCCA Area Rep SoCal

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

            Thanks guys!!!

            Update: 02-24-2012
            Mileage: 39,834 miles

            Driver Side:


            Passenger Side:


            There's not much brake dust accumulation at this point. I need more driving time to see heavier brake dust. This is the only time I wish I had more brake dust LOL! Can someone loan me a German car for testing purposes?

            The things we do for Meguiar's... errr I mean science.
            2011 Car Crazy Showcase SEMA Team

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

              You want to use my M3? I have to wash my wheels 2 times a day to keep them clean as yours are.
              Slava

              SK Auto Detailing
              http://skautodetailing.com

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                Ok guys. Time for an update! I've been trying to get as much brake dust accumulated in the wheels and I hope this is enough for you guys. This is the only time I wished my car produced more brake dust. I couldn't go any further because my car is filthy and I can't stand it anymore. I had to wash it.

                Date: 3/16/2012
                Mileage: 41,185 miles
                Miles driven since application: 1,640 miles
                Soap: Meguiar's Deep Crystal Car Wash
                Wash Media: Body Sponge

                Let's start with the passenger side wheel first. This wheel had both the Meguiar's Brake Dust Barrier on one side and Meguiar's Cleaner Wax on another side.

                Here's how the wheel looked prior to washing:



                Just to refresh your memory of which side is which, here's a picture showing just that: (Or you can refer to my original post for proof)



                Here's a picture of the wheels after the initial rinse:



                Here are some pictures showing the wheel face's reaction to the soap when I washed it. The picture below shows the side where the Brake Dust Barrier is applied:



                As you can see, the soap seems like it didn't want to stick to the surface. This could be because of the Brake Dust Barrier coating. On the other hand, the picture below shows the side where the cleaner wax is applied:



                As you can see, there's nothing special about it. The soap seems to cling onto the surface.

                Here's a picture of the wheels after rinsing the soap residue off resulting in a clean wheel:



                This picture clearly shows that the Brake Dust Barrier side is beading like there's no tomorrow while the side with cleaner wax isn't.

                Here are some videos I took as well to show you guys how the water reacts to each side.

                Below is the video prior to soaping the wheel down:



                Below is the video after soaping the wheel down:

                2011 Car Crazy Showcase SEMA Team

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                  Now let's move on with the driver side wheel. This wheel had only the Meguiar's Brake Dust Barrier on one side and it was uncoated on another side as a control.

                  Here's how the wheel looked prior to washing:



                  Just to refresh your memory of which side is which, here's a picture showing just that: (Or you can refer to my original post for proof)



                  Here's a picture of the wheels after the initial rinse:



                  Here's a picture of the wheels after soaping it:



                  Here's a picture of the wheels after rinsing the soap residue off resulting in a clean wheel: (sorry for the bad lighting. It was getting dark)



                  Again, this picture clearly shows that the Brake Dust Barrier side is beading like there's no tomorrow while the uncoated side isn't.

                  Here are some videos I took as well to show you guys how the water reacts to each side.

                  Below is the video prior to soaping the wheel down:



                  Below is the video after soaping the wheel down:



                  *** Please notice the tape line on the spoke located in the 7-8 o'clock. You can clearly see the side with Brake Dust Barrier repelling the water while the water attaches to the uncoated side.
                  2011 Car Crazy Showcase SEMA Team

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                    Observations:
                    • It seems like the Brake Dust Barrier provides a coating of some sort. It also provides relentless water beading.
                    • The side where the Brake Dust Barrier is applied feels slicker than the side with cleaner wax or the uncoated side.
                    • This product doesn't repel brake dust at all. The brake dust clings to the coated, waxed and uncoated surfaces almost equally.
                    • This product doesn't make it easier to rinse off the brake dust with water. However, my water pressure is low. Using a pressure washer can alter my results.
                    • This product may make it easier to wash off the brake dust with soap or wheel cleaners especially when heavy accumulation is present. I just wasn't able to produce a lot of brake dust in my case. However, if you regularly wash and maintain your wheels, it really won't make a difference.
                    • The cleaner wax didn't look like it survived the extreme heat produced by the vehicle's brakes. The side with cleaner wax reacts the same way with the uncoated side.



                    Conclusion:
                    This product definitely works! It provides you with a coating that lasts a long time and will help clean up your wheels a lot easier. It lasts a long time - definitely more than your traditional wax applied on the wheels. I will definitely use this product from now on so that my wheels are fully protected. You need to try this product out. It's worth the money and you won't be disappointed.


                    What do you guys think of my review? Hope you guys liked it and I hope it helps. If you guys have any comments or criticisms, please feel free to let me know. Thanks for your time!
                    2011 Car Crazy Showcase SEMA Team

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                      Thanks Marc, very helpful.
                      Questions - runs remain visible? Overspray on tires comes off easily with alcohol? Waxing on top of Barrier adds nothing? Will Barrier hold up to brushing?

                      "fishing for swirls in a sea of black"
                      ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
                      David

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                        Hi David,

                        I didn't visually see the runs anymore. They were very minor. It probably got baked from the intense heat produced by the brake system. Yes the overspray on the tires were easily wiped off with alcohol. Please keep in mind I did this after spraying the wheel. It might be more difficult if you let it dry. I have not tried waxing on top of the Barrier. I don't think there's any reason to do it. My test shows that cleaner wax is completely killed off. The BDB survived a month long driving. I think BDB will hold up to brushing but I didn't try. Maybe I'll use my wheel brush on my next wash and update you guys.
                        2011 Car Crazy Showcase SEMA Team

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                          Great review! My wheels are totally trashed with corrosion from the previous owner but if I ever get them refinished I will be using this for sure.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                            BDB will indeed hold up to brushing, wheel cleaners, etc.

                            Marc, your water pressure looked pretty normal for just water coming out of the hose. We wouldn't expect that alone to be enough to fully clean the wheels, but a pressure washer should. Also, for cars that deposit heavy break dust (those pesky German brake pads!) where a wheel cleaner is almost always needed in conjunction with a bit of agitation, you'll find that just a light once over with some soap and water will do the trick. In those cases of heavy German brake dust, often just a pressure washer is enough to get everything off.

                            Yes, BDB is leaving a very hydrophobic coating on the wheels, which explains the water beading you're seeing on the treated side. This is NOT the same hydrophobic effect obtained with the polymers in products like NXT 2.0, UQW, UQD or even Ultimate Wax. BDB is a totally different chemical makeup that achieves a "lotus effect" type of protection.
                            Michael Stoops
                            Senior Global Product & Training Specialist | Meguiar's Inc.

                            Remember, this hobby is supposed to be your therapy, not the reason you need therapy.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Meguiar's Hot Rims Brake Dust Barrier Review and Testing

                              Lotus effect?
                              2017 Subaru WRX Premium - WR Blue

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X
                              gtag('config', 'UA-161993-8');